The Alamo Controversy: Should We Remember or Forget? | Ep 51

John Wayne believed the Battle of the Alamo represented American values and patriotism. Some people today think it represents things we should forget. What’s the real story? Michael and Tony break it down and consider what matters and why?

The video ‘The Alamo Controversy: Should We Remember or Forget?’ from the channel Saving the Dream features a discussion on the historical and cultural significance of the Alamo. It explores the perspectives presented in the book ‘Forget the Alamo’ by Christalmonson, the romanticization of the battle, and the broader implications of how history is remembered and taught. The conversation also touches on the influence of Mexican culture on the American West and the complexities of historical interpretation.


  • The Alamo is often romanticized in American culture, notably through John Wayne’s portrayal in his film, which was not shot at the actual Alamo.
  • The defenders of the Alamo, including Travis, Bowie, and Crockett, were motivated by manifest destiny and a desire for adventure, despite differing opinions on the strategic importance of the Alamo.
  • Santa Anna’s centralized control over Mexico and his decision to engage at the Alamo were pivotal in the Texas Revolution, with the battle resulting in significant losses for his forces.
  • Critics argue that the Alamo narrative perpetuates mistreatment of Mexican Americans, yet the video presents personal experiences and historical nuances that challenge this assertion.
  • The influence of Mexican culture, particularly through charros, on the development of Western American culture and the cowboy lifestyle is highlighted.
  • The video questions the need to hold onto past grievances regarding the Alamo and suggests a more symbolic interpretation of the event.
  • The conquest of the West is likened to a conquest of nature, emphasizing the challenges faced by settlers and the pioneering spirit of Americans.
  • The importance of understanding historical events and figures within their respective time periods and values is stressed, arguing against imposing contemporary values on past events.
  • The video concludes with a reflection on the moral complexities of storytelling and the significance of Hollywood’s portrayal of history.

SAVING THE DREAM is an unconventional podcast featuring real people talking about life in America. If you’re enjoying life in the echo chamber where people don’t really listen and think, then this one isn’t for you. But if you like honest exchanges about things that affect everyday life, then tune in here for a new episode each week. With Michael O’Sullivan and a varying slice of the Saving the Dream crew.